The Ice Moose is a Christmas double-length story from the second seasonand the 60th story overall of PB&J Otter. In this story, PB&J and their friends and family celebrate Hoohaw Hoo, the Lake Hoohaw equivalent of Christmas. To celebrate the holiday, they have a pageant. Aunt Nanner is slated to play Old Tim, the Ice Moose, but comes down with a bad case of otter flu not long before the pageant. The kids to enlist Flick as a replacement, but Flick is down on the holiday, having only received a pair of underwear for Hoohaw Hoo and not the fancy presents that he wished for. He doesn't believe in Old Tim and only briefly agrees to play the role before stalking off in distaste. Along the way, he meets Simon Fieldmouse, a small, poor mouse who wishes that he could fly. Hearing Simon's wish, Flick's annoyance with the holiday begins to melt, but he has to learn to fly himself before he can help Simon.